In a surprising turn of events, a Missouri court has awarded damages worth $47,000 against Kimberly R. Weger for refusing to release a mortgage that had been paid off by the Barbers, a Missouri couple trying to sell their property. The court ruled on November 17, 2026, that Weger's actions were unjustified and went against the evidence presented. The Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District, found no valid financial reason for Weger to block the sale after the loan was paid off. The ruling also upheld a separate legal penalty of $3,732.50, plus $28,065.77 in legal fees and court costs. The appeals court has sent the case back to the lower court to decide on extra legal fees from the appeal.

The dispute centered around a property at 4905 West Route F in Clark, Missouri, and focused on a dispute over payments made almost ten years before the planned sale. In 2006, the Barbers bought the property from Kimberly Weger and her husband, Aubrey Weger. The buyers signed a loan agreement for $37,325 to cover part of the purchase price. A deed of trust was also filed in favor of the Wegers on November 22, 2006, giving them a legal claim over the property until the loan was paid in full.

In April 2022, the Barbers signed a deal to sell the property for $272,500. However, before the sale could close, they learned that the deed of trust in favor of the Wegers was still listed against the property. The former sellers refused to clear it, saying they had not received every monthly payment, especially those from 2014 and 2015. Despite numerous attempts by the Barbers to resolve the issue, including hiring a lawyer and offering to put any disputed money into a secure holding account, the Wegers still refused to give a payoff amount or release the deed of trust. This led to the collapse of the sale, prompting the Barbers to file a lawsuit in Boone County Circuit Court on August 19, 2022.

During the trial, Brenda maintained that she and Joseph made every payment owed under the loan. However, Weger claimed that only 67 of the 107 required payments were made, leaving $17,079.97 unpaid, not counting late fees. Despite this, the court ruled in favor of the Barbers, citing insufficient evidence to support Weger's claims. The court's decision has set a precedent for property sales in Missouri, emphasizing the importance of clear and timely mortgage releases.