In a legal setback for the owners, a federal judge has dismissed an amended lawsuit challenging the city's restrictions on demolishing Marilyn Monroe's former home in Los Angeles. Brinah Milstein and Roy Bank, who purchased the property in 2023, argued that its historic-cultural monument designation violated their property rights and turned their private residence into a tourist nuisance. The house, located at 12305 Fifth Helena Drive, was purchased by Monroe in 1962 and was the only home she ever owned independently. Despite the owners' claims that the house had undergone extensive renovations since Monroe's death, public opposition and historical significance led to its designation as a historic-cultural monument in 2024, preventing demolition or substantial alterations without city permission. The owners alleged that the designation caused security problems due to tourist congestion, drones, trespassing, and even an alleged burglary. However, the court ruled against their constitutional claims, allowing the historic designation to remain in place.
The owners of Marilyn Monroe's former home have lost their legal battle against the city of Los Angeles, which has upheld the historic-cultural monument designation protecting the property. Brinah Milstein and Roy Bank argued that the designation had deprived them of their property rights while turning their private residence into a tourist nuisance due to unwanted attention from fans, historians, preservationists, and local residents. The house, located in the Brentwood neighborhood, was purchased by Monroe in 1962 and was the only home she ever owned independently. Despite the owners' claims that the house had undergone extensive renovations over the decades, it remains a significant part of Hollywood history. The city initiated proceedings for historic-cultural monument status in September 2023, and the Los Angeles City Council unanimously approved the designation in June 2024, protecting the property from demolition or substantial alterations without city permission.
A federal judge has dismissed an amended lawsuit filed by the owners of Marilyn Monroe's former home, who were challenging restrictions that prevented them from demolishing the property. Brinah Milstein and Roy Bank argued that the house's historic-cultural monument designation had violated their property rights and turned their private residence into a tourist nuisance due to unwanted attention and security problems caused by visitors, tour buses, trespassers, drones, and even an alleged burglary. The house, located at 12305 Fifth Helena Drive in Los Angeles, was purchased by Monroe in 1962 and was the only home she ever owned independently. Despite the owners' claims that the house had undergone extensive renovations over the decades, it remains a significant part of Hollywood history. The city initiated proceedings for historic-cultural monument status in September 2023, and the Los Angeles City Council unanimously approved the designation in June 2024, preventing demolition or substantial alterations without city permission.