In a ruling handed down by the Ohio Court of Appeals for the Twelfth District on November 16, 2026, Jackson & Jackson, LLC has been granted an opportunity to challenge county zoning restrictions on a nine-acre property they purchased for $270,000 in 2021. The property, located at 5670 West Alexandria Road, Madison Township, Butler County, Ohio, has a long history of commercial and community use despite being situated in an R-1 Suburban Residence District. The company, which specializes in commercial electrical services, had its claim that the zoning restrictions amounted to an unconstitutional taking of private property without compensation restored after the appeals court found errors in the lower court's decision. The case, Dickard v. Jackson & Jackson, L.L.C., will be returned to the Butler County Court of Common Pleas for further proceedings, with the appeals court ruling that two of the company's claims should not have been dismissed at such an early stage.
The disputed property was previously used as a golf driving range, pizza shop, and church before Jackson & Jackson purchased it. The county zoning inspector challenged the company's commercial operations on the site in May 2023, arguing that they were not allowed under the R-1 residential zoning rules. Jackson & Jackson applied for a use variance to park their vehicles on the property and use an existing building as an administrative office, but this was rejected by the Butler County Board of Zoning Appeals in August 2023. The company continued operating its business from the property despite this rejection and faced a lawsuit from zoning inspector Dennis Dickard, who sought an injunction ordering them to stop breaking the county's zoning rules.
Jackson & Jackson responded with a counterclaim against the county, arguing that the restrictions were unconstitutional when applied to their property. The company based this argument on the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments to the US Constitution. The amended counterclaim included three separate claims, with the first asking the court to declare that the zoning rules were unconstitutional when applied to their property. The case is recorded as Dickard v. Jackson & Jackson, L.L.C., case number CA2025-07-072, and citation 2026-Ohio-4530. Judge Mary Donovan wrote the opinion, with Presiding Judge Robin N. Piper and Judge Mike Powell agreeing. The ruling could have significant implications for other property owners facing similar zoning restrictions in Butler County.
