In a shocking turn of events, an Indiana mother's bid to regain sole custody of her three children and access to her former husband's mental health records has been denied by the Indiana Court of Appeals. Sember Darland-Chappell, who divorced Andrew Hahn in 2020, must now pay $18,500 towards his trial lawyer's fees, as per a ruling issued on 16 November 2026. The court also approved Hahn's request for appellate legal fees and sent the case back to the trial court to decide additional costs. Judge Cale Bradford presided over the decision, with Judges Patricia Riley Bailey and Elaine Brown Altice concurring.

The bitter custody battle between Darland-Chappell and Hahn has been ongoing for seven years. Under their original divorce order, the former couple shared legal custody of their children born in 2009, 2011, and 2013, but Darland-Chappell had primary physical custody. Hahn was granted regular parenting time. However, disputes escalated when Hahn sought to change legal custody and parenting time in June 2021.

Darland-Chappell responded with a request for a formal child custody evaluation, which clinical psychologist Dr Bart Ferraro conducted between February and May 2022. The trial court heavily relied on Dr Ferraro's recommendations, granting Hahn sole legal custody in May 2023 and altering the physical parenting schedule. Darland-Chappell filed a request to regain custody in November 2023, which was rejected in May 2024 following a three-day hearing.

Controversy arose over therapy records and the appointment of a guardian ad litem. After a new judge took over the case, Darland-Chappell requested the court to appoint an independent person to represent the children's interests. This request was denied in March 2025, and Darland-Chappell also sought to speak privately with all three children and subpoena records held by their therapist.

The trial court ultimately rejected Darland-Chappell's request for Hahn's mental health records, citing potential harm to Hahn as a patient. The judge explained that court-ordered therapy was intended to help the children adjust and improve their relationship with their father. The decision followed an earlier warning from the court that therapy was not meant to be used as ammunition in further hearings.

In conclusion, Sember Darland-Chappell's appeal to regain custody of her children has been denied by the Indiana Court of Appeals. She is now required to pay $18,500 towards her former husband's legal fees and faces additional costs yet to be determined. The longstanding custody battle between Darland-Chappell and Andrew Hahn continues, with no signs of resolution in sight.