Former Australia all-rounder Moises Henriques has lauded Steve Smith as a national hero for taking full responsibility for the 2018 ball-tampering scandal, despite not being involved in the planning. According to Cameron Bancroft's latest account of Sandpapergate, Smith distanced himself from the plan when it was discussed but accepted the blame publicly when the scandal erupted. Henriques believes that Smith's decision to protect his teammates sets him apart, as he could have named those involved but chose not to.

In a lengthy account published on Wednesday, Bancroft claimed that Smith had distanced himself from the plan and did not approve of it. However, when the scandal broke, Smith stood alongside Bancroft at the press conference, accepting responsibility and not implicating other team members. Henriques argued that this decision demonstrates Smith's leadership and integrity, as he could have easily thrown others under the bus but chose to take the blame instead.

Former Australia captain Michael Clarke, however, believes Smith still had a responsibility to act, regardless of whether he approved of the plan. Speaking on the Beyond23 Cricket Podcast, Clarke acknowledged that Smith took the punishment and returned to the game but said the responsibility of leadership could not be separated from what happened. According to Clarke, as captain, Smith had a duty to take a stand against such behavior, even if he was not directly involved in the plan.

The ball-tampering scandal erupted during the Cape Town Test in March 2018, when Bancroft was caught using sandpaper on the ball. The incident led to a significant backlash and resulted in Smith being handed a 12-month ban and removed as Australia captain. Cricket Australia has since announced a forum for players and staff from the 2018 tour to share their recollections, while ruling out a formal reinvestigation. With Bancroft's account reopening questions about what happened in Cape Town, Henriques and Clarke have offered contrasting perspectives on Smith's role in the incident: one focused on his decision not to implicate teammates, and the other on the responsibility he carried as captain.